Carnegie mellon vs Toledo — US university comparison
KEY DATA
HEAD-TO-HEAD STATISTICS
EXPERT TAKE
Carnegie mellon is the more selective of the two (11.7% vs 92% acceptance). Carnegie mellon ranks higher in the ARWU world research ranking (#101-150 vs #601-700). Carnegie mellon graduates earn a higher median 10 years after enrollment ($115K vs $51K). Toledo has lower sticker-price tuition ($22,104 vs $66,246 per year).
Both universities have complete, comparable data in canonical — the choice should come down to fit (campus culture, major, aid package) alongside the differences visible in the numbers below.
Choose Carnegie mellon for: a higher world ranking, higher selectivity, higher graduate earnings.
Choose Toledo for: lower tuition, lower graduate debt.
College Council Atlas analysis · IPEDS / College Scorecard CDS 2024-25, ARWU 2024.
BY THE NUMBERS
Carnegie mellon is more selective (11.7% vs 92% acceptance); Carnegie mellon has a higher median SAT (1546 vs 1235).
Carnegie mellon graduates earn a higher median 10 years after enrollment ($115K vs $51K); Carnegie mellon has a higher 6-year graduation rate (94.1% vs 57%).
Toledo has lower sticker-price tuition ($22,104 vs $66,246); Carnegie mellon offers a larger average aid package ($60,909 vs $14,444).
VALUE LANDSCAPE
FULL DATA TABLE
| Metric | Carnegie mellon | Toledo |
|---|---|---|
| World rank · ARWU | #101-150 | #601-700 |
| Rank · THE | #24 | — |
| Acceptance rate | 11.7% | 92% |
| Yield rate | 45.7% | 18.8% |
| Median SAT | 1546 | 1235 |
| Avg. GPA | 3.90 | — |
| Number of applications | 33,941 | 11,067 |
| International students | 46% | 9% |
| Median earnings · 10 yrs | $115K | $51K |
| Avg. earnings · 10 yrs | $103K | $53K |
| Top 25% earnings · 10 yrs | $183K | $77K |
| Graduation rate | 94.1% | 57% |
| Retention rate | 98% | 77.3% |
| Median debt | $21,750 | $22,250 |
| Tuition · year | $66,246 | $22,104 |
| Avg. aid package | $60,909 | $14,444 |
| % of need met | 100% | 61% |
| Avg. graduate debt | $31,298 | $23,487 |
| Application fee | $75 | $40 |
| Enrollment | 16,676 | 14,358 |
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Is it harder to get into Carnegie mellon or Toledo?
It's harder to get into Carnegie mellon. Carnegie mellon accepts 11.7% of applicants, while Toledo accepts 92%.
Do Carnegie mellon or Toledo graduates earn more?
Carnegie mellon graduates earn more: the median 10 years after enrollment is $115K vs $51K.
How much is tuition at Carnegie mellon vs Toledo?
Sticker-price tuition is $66,246 per year at Carnegie mellon and $22,104 per year at Toledo.
What SAT score do you need for Carnegie mellon or Toledo?
The median admitted SAT score is 1546 at Carnegie mellon and 1235 at Toledo; aim for these values or higher to be competitive.
Which university ranks higher — Carnegie mellon or Toledo?
Carnegie mellon ranks higher in the ARWU world ranking: #101-150 for Carnegie mellon vs #601-700 for Toledo.
Which university offers more financial aid — Carnegie mellon or Toledo?
The average aid package is $60,909 at Carnegie mellon and $14,444 at Toledo.
Harvard
Stanford
Massachusetts institute of technology
Princeton
Yale
Cornell
Penn
Johns hopkins
Washington university
Northwestern